Many dogs, regardless of age or breed, love to chew, whether it’s your favorite pair of shoes or the remote control. Since young dogs are notorious chewers, finding the best indestructible dog toys can save your clothing, furniture, and personal items from severe damage. However, finding a toy that’s indestructible is a big challenge, especially if you have a young dog that seems to go through toys in a matter of minutes or hours.
I’ve created this buyer’s guide to discuss what pet owners should look for in a new dog toy that will indicate how durable the toy is. This will help pet owners save a fortune on replacing chewed up personal items, while also avoiding purchasing low-quality dog toys that a pet can quickly tear to shreds. My dog has also tried out several of the most popular models on the market, leaving just four toys that were able to withstand some serious chewing. Below, you’ll find a comparison chart that includes each of the models that survived, how they rated, and other important information.
Table of Contents
Indestructible Dog Toys Comparison Chart
| Product | Material | Size Options | Breed Type | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pet Qwerks Dinosaur BarkBone Chew Toy   Shop On Amazon! | Nylon | 4 | L-XXXL | |
| Arm & Hammer Super Treadz Chew Toy   Shop On Amazon! | Rubber | 1 | L | |
Nylabone Dog Toy  Shop On Amazon! | Nylon | 5 | S-XL | |
Aduksa Indestructible Dog Toy  Shop On Amazon! | Polymer nylon | 1 | M-L |
Pet Qwerks Dinosaur Bark Bone Chew Toy
Our Rating:
This nylon large bone is flavored with real bacon. It’s designed to last and made specifically for aggressive chewers. This toy can also help to relieve boredom, which can lead to destructive behaviors in some dogs. The bone will also help to scrape plaque off the teeth, for healthy gums and teeth. Unlike competing chew toys, this model can withstand hours of chewing from large to XXXL breed dogs. Because of the size, it’s not recommended for toy or small breeds.
Pros
- Available in four size options
- Designed for large to XXXL breed dogs
- Promotes oral health
- Flavored with real bacon
Cons
- Not designed for dogs under forty pounds
Conclusion
This bone will provide countless hours of entertainment for aggressive chewers. It also promotes oral health by removing plaque buildup on the teeth. Dogs will love the real bacon flavor, which will keep a dog preoccupied for hours on end. Made out of durable nylon, this toy will not break, chip, or crack, which is a huge plus for any pet owner who’s tired of having to replace dog toys that have been torn to shreds in a matter of minutes.
Arm & Hammer Super Treadz Gorilla Chew Toy
Our Rating:
This toy by Arm & Hammer is made out of all-natural rubber and is designed specifically with aggressive chewers in mind. If you’re having trouble finding a dog toy that your dog isn’t able to tear apart, then this massive durable rubber gorilla is the perfect choice. Able to easily withstand the powerful jaws of large and extra-large breeds, this chew toy will keep your dog happy and occupied for hours. The large gorilla shape does an excellent job of enticing playful pups and adults and can keep them distracted as they chew the large supportive surface that also works to improve oral health. The toy is designed to stimulate the gums, breaking down the tartar on the surface of the teeth. Not only can this help to prevent gum disease, but it also works to freshen their breath.
Pros
- Dishwasher safe
- Promotes gum health
- Removes plaque buildup
- Durable
Cons
- Available in one size only
- Not recommended for small breeds
Conclusion
This model is dishwasher safe, so you can toss it in the dishwasher whenever it gets dirty. Additionally, the toy is also infused with baking soda, which will help to cut down on odors and can prevent bacteria growth. This large, colorful toy is a great choice for the avid chewer and the dog that is normally able to tear right through their toys.
Nylabone Dog Toy
Our Rating:
This nylon chew toy by Nylabone is available in five size options and is designed to satisfy the need to chew by providing a durable chewing surface that’s peanut butter flavored, so every dog is sure to love it. This bone-shaped toy is designed for small up to extra-large dogs, and can help to prevent boredom and destructive behaviors. The durable surface will help to scrape plaque buildup on your pet’s teeth, while also stimulating the gums for improved blood flow. This bone is a great choice for dogs of all ages and sizes and will not chip, break, or crack.
Pros
- Durable
- Peanut butter flavored
- Made out of nylon
- Five size options to choose from
Cons
- Not dishwasher safe
Conclusion
This bone is the perfect toy for dogs who love to chew. The strong peanut butter flavor and scent will entice any dog, keeping them happy and entertained hour after hour. This model is available in five size options, so you can choose the perfect size based on breed.
Aduksa Indestructible Dog Toy
Our Rating:
This model is made out of nontoxic, bite-resistant polymer nylon. This material is industrial strength and approved for large breed dogs. This toy will help to meet a dog’s instinctive need to chew and also works to keep their teeth clean and free from plaque. The manufacturer also offers a lifetime replacement guarantee, so you can request a replacement in the event your dog is able to tear it apart. This model is approved for medium and large breed dogs only and is not recommended for small or extra-large breeds.
Pros
- Lifetime replacement guarantee
- Made out of polymer nylon
- Bite-resistant
Cons
- Is not flavored
- Not designed for small or extra-large breed dogs
Conclusion
Unfortunately, this model is available in one size only and is a good choice for medium and large breed dogs but is not recommended for small breeds or extra-large breeds. The toy is also not flavored, which can be a drawback for some buyers, since dogs are more likely to play with a flavored chew toy. However, this is a great buy for aggressive chewers who will gnaw on pretty much anything. The durable design and lifetime replacement guarantee will allow pet owners to request a replacement product in the event their dog is able to tear this toy apart. The low cost and replacement guarantee combined with the colorful, durable design will give pet owners every reason to buy.
Indestructible Dog Toys Buyer’s Guide
The right toys are multipurpose and can work to satisfy a dog’s instinct to chew. However, they should also be fun for your dog to play with. Toys that are designed to store treats inside can also provide your dog with much-needed mental stimulation and will keep them occupied for hours. But before I dive into what features to look for in your pet’s next toy, let’s learn more about the importance of giving your dog toys and the many benefits they’ll enjoy from having appropriate chew toys.
Benefits of Indestructible Dog Toys
- Purchasing toys for your pet will provide both mental and physical stimulation. These toys will prevent your dog from becoming bored, which can lead to destructive behaviors around the home or yard, such as chewing on the furniture, or digging holes in the backyard.
- A toy can also help to remove or prevent plaque buildup on your dog’s teeth.
- Having toys will help to satisfy your dog’s natural desire to chew, saving your personal items from damage.
- Dog toys are affordable and a great way to reward your dog for good behavior
- Puppies will go through a teething phase, which can cause them to chew on their owner’s personal belongings and pretty much anything else they can get their paws on. A good, durable toy will help to satisfy their need to chew and will also feel good on their sore gums.
Important Factors
The toy you choose will depend on your dog’s play and chewing style. Some pets are avid chewers, while other dogs are fetchers. Before you begin shopping for a toy, there are some important factors to take into consideration, which I’ll go over below.
Safety
- When selecting a new toy for your dog, safety will be very important. The best chew toys will be made out of hard rubber. These toys are very chew resistant and can handle a beating from an aggressive chewer. Low quality toys can easily be ripped apart, which can be dangerous if your dog swallows any part of the toy, especially any stuffing.
- Dogs that love to chew often quickly tear their toys apart, which is why you’ll want to avoid any toys that contain a squeaker, since these can easily be swallowed and pose a serious choking hazard.
- A standard rope toy can also be very dangerous if you allow your dog to chew on one unattended. The threads of these toys often get caught in a dog’s digestive tract and can bind up the dog’s intestines.
- Plush toys are also a bad option since they contain cotton filling that can be swallowed once your dog tears the toy apart. If you have a large breed dog, then it can tear open one of these toys in a matter of minutes.
- If you have a dog that’s an aggressive chewer, then you’ll need to search for a toy that offers a little give, so you won’t risk a young pup breaking or chipping their teeth.
Durability
Of course durability is essential. The most durable toys on the market are often made out of tough, thick rubber or nylon. These toys can handle even the most aggressive chewer and cannot easily be torn apart.
Toys that are marketed as indestructible are designed to handle rough play and aggressive dogs. Toys that are more durable will be large, heavy, and difficult for your dog to chew through.
How hard-wearing a toy is will often be determined by the type of material it’s made out of. For dogs, destroying a toy is part of the game. Some dogs will prefer to gently chew on their toy and carry it around the house or yard, but the aggressive chewer wants to totally annihilate it. A toy that’s indestructible will be a true challenge for a dog. But in reality, there really is no toy that can be considered indestructible. Instead, you’ll come across some toys that are significantly more durable than others. These toys may last several weeks or months before your dog is able to tear them apart.
Age Appropriate Toys
It will definitely be easier to find a durable dog toy that’s designed for puppies than it will be to find one for an adult large breed dog. However, for puppies, you need to be careful not to purchase a toy that’s too tough, since this can damage their teeth. Read the manufacturer’s product description closely when you’re shopping for a new toy. The manufacturer will clearly list the age of dog the toy is appropriate for.
Material
You’ll find dog toys made out of hard nylon, plastic, rubber, and even polyester material. The trick here is finding a toy that’s made out of tough material, but not too tough. Some types of hard nylon or plastic have been known to crack a dog’s teeth, while toys that are too soft can easily be torn apart. A dog toy should be made out of durable material that has a little give, which will satisfy a dog’s desire to chew, without damaging their teeth.
Size
Choose a toy based on your dog’s size. You won’t want to give your small breed dog a toy that’s too large for them to carry around, or one that they have a hard time chewing on. You also want to make sure the toy is large enough to withstand the powerful jaws of a large breed dog. You can easily determine whether or not a toy is suitable for your breed of dog by eyeballing it. However, when you shop online, the pictures can be somewhat misleading, so you may end up accidentally ordering a toy that’s too big or too small. To avoid this, make sure you read the product description, which will normally recommend the breed size.
Price
These types of dog toys are going to be pricier than the soft plush dog toys you can commonly find at your local pet store. However, the higher price is often worth it since these toys will not need to be replaced as often and are made out of high quality materials that are designed to withstand your dog’s sharp teeth.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why Do Dogs Rip Out Stuffing From Toys?
Dogs do this because of their prey drive. Some stuffed animals look similar to prey. A dog’s ancestors used to hunt. The presence of a plush toy may trigger your dog’s prey drive and can cause them to hunt and kill their toy. Some dogs are simply just destructive so it’s also possible that your dog is doing this because they are bored.
Are Antlers Bad for Dogs?
No. Antlers are very tough and can last much longer compared to other chew toys. Additionally, they don’t fall apart and will not splinter.
Are Hard Chew Toys Bad for Dogs?
Some types of chew toys can be too hard for a young dog’s teeth. If you have a younger dog, avoiding giving them a chew toy that’s made out of a hard plastic or hard nylon. A dog may end up breaking or cracking a tooth, which can lead to a costly vet visit.
Should You Give Dogs Ice Cubes?
Ice cubes are perfectly safe for dogs. Some vets even recommend giving dogs ice cubes as a treat. They’re safe to chew on and they can be very refreshing for your pet when it’s hot outside.
Final Thoughts
The best indestructible dog toys will provide your dog with hours of entertainment, while satisfying their need to chew. This can save plenty of wear and tear on the furniture, your shoes, clothing, and other personal items. Many of these toys will also promote oral health since they can help to prevent plaque buildup. Just like a child, a young dog needs toys for mental stimulation and physical stimulation. This will keep your pet happy, busy, and generally entertained. Purchasing a few of these toys will prevent your dog from quickly becoming bored, which can also lead to destructive behaviors.
